SCEC CVM-H Depth Slices
P velocity: 0 km 0.2 km 0.4 km 0.6 km 0.8 km 1.0 km 1.2 km 1.4 km 1.6 km 1.8 km 2.0 km 2.2 km 5 km 10 km 20 km 30 km 40 km 50 km 60 km 70 km 80 km
S velocity: 0 km 0.2 km 0.4 km 0.6 km 0.8 km 1.0 km 1.2 km 1.4 km 1.6 km 1.8 km 2.0 km 2.2 km 5 km 10 km 20 km 30 km 40 km 50 km 60 km 70 km 80 km
density: 0 km 0.2 km 0.4 km 0.6 km 0.8 km 1.0 km 1.2 km 1.4 km 1.6 km 1.8 km 2.0 km 2.2 km 5 km 10 km 20 km 30 km 40 km 50 km 60 km 70 km 80 km
Slices that are at different depths below topography/bathymetry
P velocity: 0 m 10 m 150 m 250 m 500 m
S velocity: 0 m 10 m 150 m 250 m 500 m
density : 0 m 10 m 150 m 250 m 500 m
Comparison of CVMH synthetics with the CVM4 synthetics at 0.2 Hz
Differential travel-time for the transverse compnents:
Observed Waveform w.r.t. CVM4 Synthetic
CVMH Synthetic w.r.t. CVM4 Synthetic
Observed Waveform w.r.t. CVMH Synthetic
Transverse-Component Waveform Comparions Plotted with Shear-wave Speeds Cross-section Views
(black line: data, red line: CVMH synthetics, blue line: CVM4 synthetics)
AZ.BZN AZ.CRY AZ.FRD AZ.KNW AZ.MONP AZ.PFO AZ.RDM AZ.SND AZ.WMC AZ.YAQ CI.ADO CI.AGA CI.ALP CI.BAR CI.BBR CI.BBS CI.BEL CI.BOR CI.BTP CI.CAP CI.CCC CI.CHF CI.CIA CI.CPP CI.CTC CI.DEC CI.DEV CI.DGR CI.DNR CI.DPP CI.DVT CI.EML CI.HEC CI.HLL CI.JCS CI.LDR CI.LKL CI.LLS CI.LRL CI.LUG CI.MLS CI.MPI CI.MPP CI.MWC CI.NBS CI.NSS CI.OLP CI.OSI CI.PAS CI.PLC CI.PLS CI.RCT CI.RIO CI.RRX CI.SBPX CI.SDR CI.SLR CI.SRN CI.STG CI.TA2 CI.VCS CI.WBS CI.WER CI.WLT
Transverse-Component Waveform Comparions Plotted with Shear-wave Speeds Difference Mapview at 6km Depth
(black line: data, red line: CVMH synthetics, blue line: CVM4 synthetics)
AZ.BZN AZ.CRY AZ.FRD AZ.KNW AZ.MONP AZ.PFO AZ.RDM AZ.SND AZ.WMC AZ.YAQ CI.ADO CI.AGA CI.ALP CI.BAR CI.BBR CI.BBS CI.BEL CI.BOR CI.BTP CI.CAP CI.CCC CI.CHF CI.CIA CI.CPP CI.CTC CI.DEC CI.DEV CI.DGR CI.DNR CI.DPP CI.DVT CI.EML CI.HEC CI.HLL CI.JCS CI.LDR CI.LKL CI.LLS CI.LRL CI.LUG CI.MLS CI.MPI CI.MPP CI.MWC CI.NBS CI.NSS CI.OLP CI.OSI CI.PAS CI.PLC CI.PLS CI.RCT CI.RIO CI.RRX CI.SBPX CI.SDR CI.SLR CI.SRN CI.STG CI.TA2 CI.VCS CI.WBS CI.WER CI.WLT
Ground Motion Prediction for Southern California
The purpose of this project is to quantify how well our Earth structure model and our numerical wave propagation simulation methods can predict observed ground motion from earthquakes in Southern California. The ground-motion simulation area is the TeraShake V3 box, the highest frequency we are studying currently is 0.2 Hz.
Four corners (clockwise), longitude and latitude (degree):
point 1: -116.0000000000000 31.70000000000000
point 2: -121.0000000000000 35.00000000000000
point 3: -119.0134549168218 37.16106662131585
point 4: -113.9393327070036 33.77248113377244
Four corners (clockwise), UTM Easting and Northing (meters):
point 1: 594765.7725272138 3507418.018956123
point 2: 132525.0797531895 3880905.789258549
point 3: 321214.8675732052 4114434.448498669
point 4: 783455.5603472295 3740946.678196243
Volume dimensions:
300.6000000000000 (km)
595.0000000000000 (km)
81.40000000000001 (km)
Coordinate for simulation:
x: from point 1 to point 4
y: from point 1 to point 2
z: from 81.4 km depth to free surface
Simulation grids:
Grid Spacing: 200 meters
Global grid # nx, ny, nz: 1504, 2976, 408
Total global grid #: 1826168832
Processor # pnx, pny, pnz: 8, 16, 8
Local grid # nxt, nyt, nzt: 188, 186, 51
Total local grid #: 1783368
2. Methodology
To compare observed and predicted ground motion, the following steps are executed in a semi-automatic fashion:
1. Once an earthquake in our modeling area happens, the waveform data recorded at CISN stations in our modeling box are retrieved. The retrieved waveform data are in SAC format and corrected for gain. The resulting seismograms are in velocity (cm/s).
2. The SAC files for the two horizontal components are rotated into Radial (R) and Transvers (T) components. The rotated seismograms together with the vertical component (R, T and Z) are then low-pass filtered using a 6-th order Butterworth filter with a corner at 0.2 Hz.
3. Our current ground-motion indicator is the Peak Ground Velocity (PGV). Therefore, the peak amplitude of each observed seismogram is picked. The PGVs picked at the stations were then interpolated to the whole area we are modeling using a stochastic interpolation algorithm similar to kriging.
4. The CMT solution for the earthquake is determined using an automated waveform inversion algorithm based on GSDF amplitude measurements and the receiver Green tensor (RGT) database constructed for our modeling volume.
5. Synthetic seismograms at the CISN stations are calculated using the CMT solution determined from the previous step and the RGT database by applying the reciprocity principle.
6. The PGVs for the synthetic seismograms are picked and interpolated to the whole modeling area using the same interpolation algorithm as used to interpolate the observed PGVs.
7. The predicted PGVs as well as the waveforms are then compared with the observed PGVs and waveforms.
3. Comparison Between CVM3.0 and CVM4.0
What have been plotted in the following figures are the differences between CVM4.0 and CVM3.0 in P(top panels), S (middle panles) wave speeds and density (lower panels). The differences are defined as V(CVM4.0) - V(CVM3.0), where V is Vp, Vs or density. Warm colors reprent positive differences (CVM4.0 has larger values than CVM3.0); cold colors represent negative differences (CVM4.0 has smaller values than CVM3.0). The color scale has a resolution of 1/100 of the range. The units are km/s for wave speed differences and kg/cm^3 for density differences. The grid spacing is 500 meters uniformly in space.
Note: the plotted values are the values actually in the models (not the values used in the simulations).
all depths (color scale adapted to different depth)
The following figures show the P, S wave speeds and density in CVM3.0
all depths (color scale adapted to the average value at each depth)
The following figures show the P, S wave speeds and density in CVM4.0.
all depths (The color scales are exactly the same as in the figures for CVM3.0.)
4. Ground Motion Prediction Experiments
Event ID: 14155260 (Ml4.9, 16 Jun 2005, "Yucaipa event")
Location: 34.058 (deg latitude), -117.0113 (deg longitude), 11.61 (km depth)
Focal mechanism used: 67 (deg strike), 62 (deg dip), 45 (deg rake)
Earth structure model used: CVM3.0/CVM4.0 with lowest S velocity clamped to 1 km/s
Wave propagation simulation code: 4-th order Staggered-grid Finite-Difference
PGV Comparison figures
(upper panel: observations; lower panel: predictions; white dots: CISN stations; black lines: major faults)
Vertical Component
Radial Component
Transverse Component
Waveform Comparison Between CVM3.0 Synthetics and Data
(blue wiggles: data seismograms; red wiggles: synthetic seismograms)
Vertical Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Radial Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Transverse Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Waveform Comparison Between CVM4.0 and CVM3.0 Synthetics
(blue wiggles: CVM3.0 synthetics; red wiggles: CVM4.0 synthetics)
Vertical Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Radial Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Transverse Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Waveform Comparison Between CVM4.0 and Data
(blue wiggles: data seismograms; red wiggles: CVM4.0 synthetics)
Vertical Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Radial Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Transverse Component zoom 1 zoom 2
Event ID: 9818433 (Ml4.8, Mw4.3, 3 Sep 2002, "Yorba Linda event")
Location: 33.91795 (deg latitude), -117.78107 (deg longitude), 9.471 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 30.0 (deg strike), 90.0 (deg dip), 0.0 (deg rake)
Waveform Comparison Between CVM_etree Synthetics and Data (0.2 Hz and lower)
(blue wiggles: data seismograms; red wiggles: CVM_etree (200m grid-spacing) synthetics)
East Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
North Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
Vertical Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
Waveform Comparison Between CVM_etree Synthetics and Data (0.5 Hz and lower)
East Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
North Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
Vertical Component zoom 1 zoom 2 zoom 3
FD synthetics in ASCII format (computed using TeraShake_2_6_4 and CVM_etree 200m grid in the TeraShake box on the SDSC IA-64 machine with 400 processors for 10 hours) can be downloaded here. The first 21 numbers are header information (first: sampling interval; second: beginning time; third: number of points); seismograms start from the 22nd number.
Event ID: 14179736 (Ml5.1, 1 Sep 2005)
Location: 33.16 (deg latitude), -115.62 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 241 (deg strike), 77 (deg dip), -15 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14186612 (Ml4.69)
Location: 35.05 (deg latitude), -119.00 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 282 (deg strike) 63 (deg dip), 99 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14179292 (Ml4.63)
Location: 33.18 (deg latitude), -115.63 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 189 (deg strike) 55 (deg dip), -94 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14178188 (Ml4.64)
Location: 33.17 (deg latitude), -115.61 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 230 (deg strike) 69 (deg dip), -32 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14178184 (Ml4.74)
Location: 33.16 (deg latitude), -115.61 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 242 (deg strike) 90 (deg dip), -8 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14151344 (Ml5.19)
Location: 33.53 (deg latitude), -116.57 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 36 (deg strike) 77 (deg dip), 32 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14138080 (Ml4.59)
Location: 35.02 (deg latitude), -119.17 (deg longitude), 14.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 248 (deg strike) 63 (deg dip), 66 (deg rake)
Event ID: 14095628 (Ml5.03)
Location: 35.39 (deg latitude), -118.62 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 198 (deg strike) 77 (deg dip), -22 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9983429 (Ml4.53)
Location: 35.04 (deg latitude), -119.13 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 70 (deg strike) 49 (deg dip), 75 (deg rake)
Event ID: 13935988 (Ml4.99)
Location: 34.31 (deg latitude), -116.85 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 43 (deg strike) 82 (deg dip), -16 (deg rake)
Event ID: 13917260 (Ml4.63)
Location: 32.23 (deg latitude), -115.80 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 189 (deg strike) 48 (deg dip), -90 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9854597 (Ml4.55)
Location: 34.80 (deg latitude), -116.27 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 176 (deg strike) 87 (deg dip), -174 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9718013 (Ml5.02)
Location: 33.51 (deg latitude), -116.51 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 48 (deg strike) 90 (deg dip), 57 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9674213 (Ml4.93)
Location: 36.02 (deg latitude), -117.88 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 247 (deg strike) 86 (deg dip), -14 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9674049 (Ml5.17)
Location: 36.02 (deg latitude), -117.87 (deg longitude), 8.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 347 (deg strike) 89 (deg dip), 178 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9627721 (Ml4.66)
Location: 34.29 (deg latitude), -116.95 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 119 (deg strike) 89 (deg dip), 166 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3321011 (Ml4.53)
Location: 34.62 (deg latitude), -116.24 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 144 (deg strike) 55 (deg dip), 85 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9114812 (Ml4.99)
Location: 34.87 (deg latitude), -116.41 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 267 (deg strike) 87 (deg dip), -21 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3320884 (Ml4.96)
Location: 34.86 (deg latitude), -116.39 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 248 (deg strike) 80 (deg dip), -24 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3321590 (Ml4.98)
Location: 34.87 (deg latitude), -116.39 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 246 (deg strike) 82 (deg dip), -23 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3321595 (Ml4.98)
Location: 34.86 (deg latitude), -116.40 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 246 (deg strike) 76 (deg dip), -17 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3320883 (Ml4.99)
Location: 34.87 (deg latitude), -116.39 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 66 (deg strike) 81 (deg dip), 10 (deg rake)
Event ID: 9109254 (Ml4.58)
Location: 34.43 (deg latitude), -116.25 (deg longitude), 14.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 163 (deg strike) 75 (deg dip), 142 (deg rake)
Event ID: 3320736 (Ml5.37)
Location: 34.44 (deg latitude), -116.25 (deg longitude), 5.0 (km depth)
Focal Mechanism: 287 (deg strike) 79 (deg dip), 25 (deg rake)